Summoner Wars rewarding gameplay and distinctive, balanced armies made it a hit. Sadly, this adaptation so utterly fails to exploit the advantages of the digital format that it feels like it was deliberately crippled to make the (much more expensive) physical version preferable. (The only improvement I noticed in this first update to the app was that highlights now use colors that are easier to see.)
- The game manual has been gutted, and is missing basic information. (The weird symbols on the dice mean "six", FYI.)
- Cards are blurry and hard to tell apart (even on the Retina iPad!). The obvious choice should have been to use symbols on the cards to indicate their special abilities with the full explanation text only appearing when the card is zoomed in, but instead Playdek somehow decided it was better to always show the cards as miniature, pixelated versions of the physical cards with their UTTERLY illegible text wasting precious screen space.
- Hand size is FIVE cards, theres plenty of space to show five, but only FOUR are shown (on my iPhone 4 - iPad shows all five) to make room for a "menu" button that could have easily been moved out of the way. (And needless to say in the frequent case that you have multiple copies of the same card in your hand, the app isnt smart enough to hide the duplicate.)
- When using an ability that allows you to recover certain cards from your discard pile, you have to manually dig through the unorganized discard pile to find the cards youre allowed to take.
- Theres no dice roll animation, but youre forced to tap on them to continue.
- A special abilitys name appears when it takes effect, but you cant tap on it to find out what it actually does.
- Cant look through a factions event cards in the store, when youre deciding whether to buy them.
- Deck building is such a hideous MESS that it makes the actual battles seem slick in comparison. Instead of the industry standard of showing each type of card and how many copies you have in your deck, each copy is shown, and its hard to tell where one group of card ends and the other begins because the cards are just shrunken versions of the physical ones with no modification for the tiny iPhone screen. And every possible add-on card is shown, including ones that you cant use because you havent paid the extra real money for them yet. Classy!